• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • Contact Us
  • WHAT FEDS DOES
  • Download FEDSVoice
FedsNews

FedsNews

FedsNews

  • National
    • Agri Business
      • Maori Agri Business
      • Marketing
      • Agri Tech
    • Biosecurity
      • Mycoplasma Bovis
      • Pest Control
    • Environment
      • Climate Change
      • Water
      • Biodiversity
    • Infrastructure
      • Transport
      • Shipping
      • Freight
      • Roading
      • Telecommunications
    • Arable, Grains & Seeds
    • Dairy
    • Forestry
    • Horticulture
    • Meat
    • Wool
  • Local
    • Councils
    • Rates
    • Compliance
  • Politics
    • Economy
    • Elections
    • Education
    • Exports
    • Immigration
    • Trade
    • Tax
  • Opinion
  • People
    • Community
    • Events
    • Employment
    • Health and Wellness
    • Training
    • On Farm
      • Adverse Events
      • Animal Welfare
      • Health and Safety
      • Awards
      • Traceability
      • NAIT
      • Welfare
    • Farm Stories
  • Podcasts
  • Videos

Feds claims Crown Pastoral Land reform “potentially unlawful”

March 11, 2021 by Leigh Catley

The Crown Pastoral Land Reform Bill is a ‘solution’ looking for a problem, and is unnecessary, counterproductive and potentially unlawful, Federated Farmers says.

Federated Farmers South Island policy manager Kim Reilly, Feds High Country member Jim Greenslade and Feds senior policy advisor Peter Wilson.

Speaking to the Environment Select Committee today, Feds South Island Policy Manager Kim Reilly said good environmental outcomes and continued sustainable and productive high country farming “can, and do, work in harmony.

“The existing contractual relationship [under the Crown Pastoral Land system] based on trust and reciprocity would be replaced by an approach of regulation, policing and enforcement.

“This diminishes the future constructiveness and openness of relationships. It reduces the certainty of leases and the incentivization to continue to invest in enhanced environmental outcomes, given no accompanying or reciprocal ability to address changing pastoral needs is provided for,” Kim said.

“The bill adds nothing except unnecessary costs, delays, complexity and red tape.”

Instead of duplicating existing district and regional council consent requirements and restrictions, it would be much more sensible to continue to improve resourcing, funding and capability processes for Land Information NZ. With reform of the RMA also on the immediate horizon it makes sense to wait to see what changes that ushers in.

South Island farmer and Federated Farmers High Country member Jim Greenslade said a flaw of the bill – as has become apparent with the Essential Freshwater regulations – is that it’s one-size fits-all approach. Far better to have contractually binding and bespoke Farm Environment Plans that take account of local conditions and particular priorities “while avoiding the need for recurring, complex and costly consent applications”.

High country farmers were very aware of land stewardship responsibilities, in particular so they can pass the Crown lease properties they have worked hard to look after and improve to the next generation. But improving the land, fencing wetlands and managing pest animals and weeds was expensive, Jim said.

The proposed pastoral land reform legislation would undermine that incentive and see money that farmers could spend on that work instead be swallowed by lawyers, consultants and consents.

Federated Farmers also questioned the lawfulness of many of the changes proposed.

“In our view, there are serious questions around the principles of natural justice, and a significant and unjust erosion of the lessee interests and rights,” Kim said.

Filed Under: Biodiversity, Environment, Lead Story, Politics Tagged With: crown pastoral land, high country

Primary Sidebar

Spotlight

EU approves methane-reducing feed additive Bovaer®

February 25, 2022 By Bronwyn Wilson

More to see

Andrew wraps the week…

Animal and plant health industry association name change

Federated Farmers and NZ Thoroughbred Breeders saddle up for mutual benefit

Preparing for new dam safety requirements

Calling all primary sector women!

Feds slams miserly EU meat and dairy quotas

Tags

Agribusiness andrew hoggard animal welfare Arable awards beef Beef+Lamb bees biosecurity climate change competition consumer councils COVID-19 Covid-19 effects dairy DairyNZ dairy prices Damien O'Connor economics economy education emissions employment environment exchange rates exports free trade agreements government health and safety innovation meat on-farm safety OSPRI rates red meat safety science sustainability technology trade transport water wool worksafe

Footer

Federated Farmers is New Zealand’s leading independent rural advocacy organisation.

The federation’s aim is to add value to the business of farming for our members and encouraging sustainability through good management practice.

Recent

  • Animal and plant health industry association name change
  • Federated Farmers and NZ Thoroughbred Breeders saddle up for mutual benefit
  • Preparing for new dam safety requirements
  • Calling all primary sector women!
  • Feds slams miserly EU meat and dairy quotas

Search

Tags

Agribusiness andrew hoggard animal welfare Arable awards beef Beef+Lamb bees biosecurity climate change competition consumer councils COVID-19 Covid-19 effects dairy DairyNZ dairy prices Damien O'Connor economics economy education emissions employment environment exchange rates exports free trade agreements government health and safety innovation meat on-farm safety OSPRI rates red meat safety science sustainability technology trade transport water wool worksafe

Federated Farmers of New Zealand